Misleading NY Times Headline About W. 30th Street Heliport

Today the New York Times ran an article glossing over the terms of the settlement cut between Friends of Hudson River Park and Air Pegasus in the West 30th Street Heliport Suit. The Settlement will be submitted to the judge for signature next week. At that point we will publish a post that lays out the terms of the settlement in more detail.

The title of PATRICK McGEEHAN's article in the Times today is "Tourist Helicopter Rides Are Set to Be Phased Out." Which is accurate, when modified with "at the West 30th Street Heliport." Although this article does mention the fact that Alvin Trenk and co. are poised to take over the South Street Heliport under the contract recently awarded to FirstFlight by the EDC, it fails to mention that Trenk Moving to South Street makes the title of the article a misnomer. It does not require any in depth analysis to see that the awarding of the contract, and the settlement have very serendipitous timing. Trenk should have no problem moving his entire operation over to South Street by 2010, where he can comfortably operate under the new FirstFlight management. This article also fails to mention that by moving the heliport 2 blocks to the north, it would fall under the "permitted uses" category, in the rules governing Hudson River Park.

When the judge signs the settlement next week, it will be a victory for the residents of the LWS and Friends of the Hudson River Park. But in reality, tourist flights are far from being phased out in NYC. When addressing the full scope of the tourist flight issue, the settlement will merely be a bandaid and a PR crutch for those on the side of the City and State who have been fielding complaints relating to this issue.

Labels: , , ,

By Turbo On 6.21.2008 At 9:39 AM

More Details on Linden Airport Management Corp. v. NYEDC


More details unfolded today, regarding the law suit filed by Linden Airport Management Corp. against the EDC. Linden's suit is claiming that the contract to operate the South Street heliport was awarded unfairly to FirstFlight. The Star Ledger published an article today, in which Paul Dudley the director of Linden Airport in NJ decribed the circumsatances giving rise to the suit. Dudley claims that Linden Airport Management Corp. submitted the most competitive bid for the South Street heliport, and that they should have been awarded the contract. According to Dudley, the EDC held a secret second round of bidding, in which FirstFlight outbid Linden and was awarded the contract. Dudley is particularly concerned by the fact that Alvin Trenk, the operator of the controversial West 30th Street heliport, is listed as one of the directors of FirstFlight. Dudley claims that Air Pegasus, also operated by Trenk gave favorable rates to certain groups at the 30th Street heliport. Other NY helicopter operators accuse Trenk of forcing them out of the 30th street heliport to eliminate competition for the sight seeing flights. Concerns have been raised that Trenk will employ the same alleged practices at South Street, under FirstFlight controlled management. According to The Star Ledger, Linden's attorney described the conditions surrounding the bidding as "decidedly not a level playing field."

Labels: , , ,

By Heli Free NYC On 6.11.2008 At 10:31 AM

Former EDC Senior Avation Official to Manage South Street Heliport on Interim Basis


In the midst of controversy over the heliport contract awarded by the EDC to FirstFlight, Ron Ricciardi, the vice chairman of FirstFlight, names Robert Grotell the interim manager of the South Street Heliport. Grotell is the former senior aviation official for the NYC Economic Development Corporation. Mr. Grotell worked as a city transportation official under Mayors Bloomberg and Giuliani, but ceased working for the City in 2004, where his title was deputy commissioner of transportation. Grotell is currently an aviation consultant. The City’s Franchise and Concession Review Committee held a hearing in response to the criticism that has arisen over the awarding of the South Street Heliport contract to FirstFlight. Many of the current helicopter operators in the NYC region feel that FirstFlight is inferior and does not have the requisite experience to operate a heliport in the metropolitan area. One local operator, Linden Airport Management Corporation has filed a suit in federal court to overturn the EDCs choice, claiming that it was biased and politically motivated. Others believe that having FirstFlight operating the heliport is a conflict of interest, give that Alvin S. Trenk, a director of First Flight owns Air Pegasus, the company operating the controversial West 30th Street heliport. Since Trenk runs a sightseeing business, other helicopter companies say that it would be unfair to have their competitor also be their landlord. Patricia Ornst, an official of the development corporation, is reported by the New York Times to have attended the hearing, but did not comment on the complaints surrounding the EDCs decision.

Labels: , ,

By Turbo On 6.03.2008 At 6:24 AM